skip to main content
Idioma:
Tipo de recurso Mostra resultados com: Mostra resultados com: Índice

Consensus and variance in Indonesian archaeology; A reply to John Miksic

Jordaan, Roy

Bijdragen tot de taal-, land- en volkenkunde, 2000, Vol.156 (1), p.169-175 [Periódico revisado por pares]

Netherlands: Brill

Texto completo disponível

Citações Citado por
  • Título:
    Consensus and variance in Indonesian archaeology; A reply to John Miksic
  • Autor: Jordaan, Roy
  • Assuntos: Archaeology ; Architecture ; Buddhism ; Buildings ; Construction ; Dating ; Discussion ; Hindus ; History of religion ; Indonesia ; Java ; Political history ; Rumors ; Sailendra ; Scholars ; Symbolism ; Temples ; Variance ; Violence
  • É parte de: Bijdragen tot de taal-, land- en volkenkunde, 2000, Vol.156 (1), p.169-175
  • Notas: istex:C351544E89228E2D6912CDD88CAB6F6DF4E02A52
    ark:/67375/JKT-0GW0N22Q-G
    href:22134379_156_01_s06_text.pdf
    ObjectType-Article-2
    SourceType-Scholarly Journals-1
    ObjectType-Feature-1
    content type line 23
  • Descrição: [...]the 1993 reference is not to this newsletter at all, but to my previous publication Imagine Buddha in Prambanan, which was negatively reviewed by Prof. Miksic himself in 1994.1 may remind him that one of the conclusions of my earlier research was that the current dating of Loro Jonggrang, which ranges from 832 (Dumarcay) to 856 (De Casparis), 'seems more inspired by conjectural interpretations of inscriptional data than by architectural and stylistic considerations'. [...]my remark that he is one of the archaeologists who allow themselves to be guided moreby De Casparis' conjectural interpretations of the Siwagrha inscription than by independent arguments (Dumarcay 1978:2-3; 1986:6, 42). [...]two alleged minor errors. When Prof. Miksic speaks highly of the intensity and quality of the debates among pre-independence Dutch scholars, and asserts that 'such an atmosphere [of consensus] is difficult to replicate even at present times, with much more favourable tools of communication at our command', I would like to remind him of the undiminished importance of close readihgs of each other's work. [...]if scholarly debates are to serve any meaningful pur- Discussion 175 pose, we must also be prepared to be persuaded by arguments.
  • Editor: Netherlands: Brill
  • Idioma: Inglês
Voltar para lista de resultados

  • Realização: ABCD-USP USP   Logos de Redes Sociais: Freepik

Buscando em bases de dados remotas. Favor aguardar.