Idioma:

Cicerone, de Inventione, 1.18: Iudicatio est, quae ex infirmatione et confirmatione rationis nascitur controversia

Pegorari, Massimiliano

Rhetorica, 2018-12, Vol.36 (1), p.1-23 [Periódico revisado por pares]

Texto completo disponível

Citações Citado por

Título:
Cicerone, de Inventione, 1.18: Iudicatio est, quae ex infirmatione et confirmatione rationis nascitur controversia
Autor: Pegorari, Massimiliano
Assuntos: Cicero, Marcus Tullius (106-43 BC) ; Latin literature ; Rhetoric
É parte de: Rhetorica, 2018-12, Vol.36 (1), p.1-23
Descrição: Cicero, in the early work de inventione (1.18), defines what is the hermagorean doctrine of ϰρινόμενον: “the point for the judge’s decision is the issue which arises from the denial (ex infirmatione) and tight assertion of the excuse (et confirmatione rationis)”. The doubts on the authenticity of the text are old, and modern editors delete the reference to the confirmatio. However, most of manuscripts attest the necessity of the confirmation of the defense. Also, confirmatio is that by means of which our speech proceeding in argument adds belief, and authority, and corroboration to our cause (de Inv., 1.34). Moreover Cicero, in Partitiones oratoriae (104), explains that only by continuous refutations between the parties to the proceedings it arises the ϰρινόμενον: this is the rhetorical counterpart of dialectic antilogy. Finally, the early medieval commentaries of the de ïnventione give reason to the firmamentum after the ϰρινόμενον.
Editor: Berkeley: Johns Hopkins University Press
Idioma: Inglês;Italiano

Voltar para lista de resultados